Now, I understand that some people have success with online dating.
I'm not really one of those people.
The problem for me is two-fold. On the internets, you're making your decision based on snap judgments. And I'm a pretty big judger. Things that I'm not into whilst online dating: fatties, 40+, generally unattractive people, and people that aren't able to write a profile without using "txt". RU the 1 I WANT? Nope. Because I would probably punch you in the face the first time you sent me a "UR A QT" text.
I'm turned off by the following things:
1. In your headline: "We can tell people we met on the el." Yawn. There's really no stigma attached to online dating anymore.
2. In your headline: "Christian Lawyer." Don't get me wrong, I like both Christians and lawyers, and hope to someday use both of those descriptors for myself, but I don't think anyone should define themselves with their religion and their profession.
3. In your profile: "I've realized that I'm not going to meet the one I want to marry at a bar." Really? You just now realized that? Because according to your profile, you're 27. I realized that when I was 22.
4. In your activities: "Wine bars," "Networking Events," "Yoga," "Climbing." To me, that combination equals douchebaggery. Especially the "Networking Events." Gurl Please. You just like open bars and rubbing elbows.
5. Saying that you "Work out 4-5 times a week." Don't get me wrong... my match.com profile says the same thing. I also put that on there when I did work out 4-5 times a week. I'll get around to doing it again sometime.
6. Seeming like a normal person in your profile when you're actually a total creeper.
7. Sending a "wink" to someone who clearly states that they're looking for someone in a 10 year age range, and you miss that age range by about 15 years. Really? Are you that full of yourself? If I say I don't want to date someone who was 45, I probably don't want to date someone who's 45. They let you pick that.
All of the above are true scenarios I've found. About #6. I went to college with this guy who, while a nice guy, is no one I'd EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER in a million years be alone in a room with... much less on a date. He's just kind of a creeper and, in my opinion, kind of psychotic (just lets you know how weird he really is), but a nice enough guy to be in normal society.
HOWEVER, his match.com profile made him seem like a normal guy. Reading it, I was kind of like, "Oh hey, he's not bad." And then I scrolled back up and actually looked at his picture and thought "Oh holy --- whew. Dodged a bullet on that one."
That was when I realized that online dating and all that was a scary thing. You can end up with real creepers that you might never know are creepers had you not gone to college with them.
Maybe I'm just annoyed because the match.com people took my money-- and I serious hopes of finding some normal people. I've been out twice. Once with someone I went to college with and whom I exchanged messages with about how awkward it was that we were both on match.com. Then he told me that the girls he works with just use it to meet random hook-ups.
The second date I had was with a man my mom called "the cat man." Yeah, he had cats. He winked at me, I winked back, we messaged, I got a little drunk one night and sent him my number. He called. We went on a date. He was dull. And we went halfsies. Worst. Date. Ever. Especially when I said, "We should do this again sometime." (Which, as we all know, means, "We should never do this again.") He replied, "Yeah, you're free on Friday, right?"
The problem of online dating is that you can see who's looked at you and think to yourself "meh" or "booyah." And then you think of all those profiles you've looked at and people you've winked at once you've said "booyah." And that you haven't gotten that many winks. Apparently your profile isn't that great, after all.
Trying to be witty or cute in your profile is a hardship. Here you're trying to do all the talking you'd do if you were at your best. [Oh, yeah, I work retail, but someday, I'm going to be a lawyer. I like to sew and cook and be real domestic. I like cats and dogs. I like the water but I don't like mean people. I think I'm kind of funny and cute.] But let's face it, you're on an online dating site, and you're clearly not at your best.
I know a few people that have had success with these things. Again, I'm not one of them.
So that is the first problem with dating websites. The second is this:
In real life, I've not conformed to any of my snap judgments in dating. Appearances have very little to do with how I feel about a person. The fun part about starting a new relationship is finding out all of those good things and bad things. Actually meeting a person and getting to know them.
To me, its not about the profile picture you put up or the headline you post. Its not about your profound musings in your profile, or your interests, or the fact that you are a professional poker player.
Its about the conversation, the smiles, the way the person looks at me and makes me feel.
You just don't get that on the interwebs.
In closing: I will not be renewing my subscription to match.com.
There are several total weirdo dating websites like:
beautifulpeople.com (which kicked a bunch of people off once they gained weight after the holidays... you have to meet a certain standard.)
eharmony.com (which doesn't allow non-Christians or the gays in, and would have been a good place for my "Christian Lawyer" friend)
jdate.com (for those of the jewish persuasion)
and my favorite:
ashleymadison.com (the online dating site for people who are married and looking for an affair. seriously.)
Please check out Sarah Haskins' (my most favorite lady comedienne/feminist cultural commentator) episode of Target Women from Current TV related to online dating, called coincidentally enough, Online Dating.
http://current.com/items/89810919_sarah-haskins-in-target-women-online-dating.htm
Her other episodes, (especially Yogurt and Barbie) are pretty fantastic also.
That being said:
If you're single, don't fret. The times, they are a-changing. We're single longer; we try to do it all, all at once. Its just the way we live (way to go, women's lib! you screwed us on that one! [or did you?]).
If you've met your soulmate on match.com, well, you're a lucky mo-fo. Most of us are just shallow enough that it gets in the way of actually meeting someone.